David Hume Kennerly/Getty Photos
On the outskirts of Grapevine, Texas, a city about 5 miles northwest of the Dallas/Fort Value Worldwide Airport, there’s a memorial devoted to the 33 airline flight crew members who misplaced their lives within the terrorist assaults on Sept. 11, 2001. Once I stumbled upon the monument a number of years in the past with my household, I skilled opposite feelings: unhappiness impressed by the memorial’s stark figures, blended with anger over how the assaults rapidly grew to become a pretext for U.S. wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Now, as U.S. troopers go away behind uncertainty and violence in Afghanistan, I look again on America’s previous 20 years with two units of eyes.
Because the first-year graduate scholar who stood smoking a cigarette in Washington Sq. Park at 8:45 a.m. on Sept. 11, 2001 – lower than a mile from the World Commerce Heart’s Twin Towers and the place the sound of the jet engines’ ultimate roar blended in with a Tuesday morning’s bustle – I really feel visceral sorrow and regret.
At the moment, as a scholar of Greek literature who research narrative and reminiscence, I see how this collective trauma formed U.S. actions and has affected Individuals’ imaginative and prescient of their identities and shared historical past – a suggestions loop that’s mirrored within the myths and histories of historical Greece.
Twenty years continues to be current historical past for a lot of, so reminiscences of the 9/11 assaults should be too uncooked to simply replicate on and study from. That’s why on the lookout for parallels in historical tales of destruction and loss may also help in understanding how shared trauma can form the tales a nation tells itself, and the choices that get made in response.
What’s “collective trauma”?
Collective trauma is a time period that describes the shared expertise of and reactions to a traumatic occasion by a gaggle of individuals. That group could also be as small as a number of individuals or as massive as an entire society.
The 9/11 assaults shattered collective American confidence in its security and sense of place on the earth. America’s collective efforts to study to dwell with that trauma partly clarify why there’s a Sept. 11 memorial in a Texas city 1000’s of miles from the place the assaults befell. It additionally demonstrates that collective tragedies can form the world views of people who weren’t current on the occasion.
The traumatized group could undergo shared levels of grief, from disbelief to anger. The additional the group will get from the traumatizing occasion itself, the nearer it strikes to social reminiscence, an idea historians use to explain how teams of individuals come to share a constant story about previous occasions. This narrative could be manipulated to replicate or implement values within the current.
Nick Ut/AP Photograph
My research of historical Greek historical past recommend to me that that is what occurred within the U.S. after the assaults. There are myths and histories of the traditional world that describe how, within the wake of the destruction of cities, societies created cultural reminiscences that helped them discover causes for speeding into conflict. These episodes have parallels to the U.S. within the early twenty first century.
Reshaping historical past by way of tales
Within the spring of 2002, I attended a New York College convention known as “Saving the Metropolis,” the place audio system have been requested to contemplate such tales. One of many histories we centered on concerned Athens after the Persian military invaded Greece – for a second time – in 480 B.C. and burned the temples, groves and houses of the Athenians. The assault was partially vengeance for a previous army loss, and likewise a punishment for Athens’ meddling in Persian affairs in Asia Minor. As with New York on Sept. 11, the attackers focused an icon: the primary model of the Athenian Parthenon.
Within the wake of this collective trauma, because the scholar Bernd Steinbock argues, narratives of metropolis destruction grew to become standard in Athenian storytelling and artwork. In a few of these tales, cities that had dedicated offenses towards the gods then suffered by the hands of worldwide armies that shaped to set them proper.
Athenians advised each other these tales as they raised troops and a navy to harry the Persians in Asia Minor. Athenian political rhetoric was formed by the specter of Persian invasion and the specter of re-invasion, the glory of victory and the casting of Athens as a pressure for freedom and justice on the earth. This rhetoric justified imperial growth, violence and finally the homicide and enslavement of town’s personal allies..
That led to the Peloponnesian Struggle, a damaging 27-year battle with Sparta that ended with Athens being conquered once more in 404 B.C.
Rhetoric and calls to arms
In 2001, Individuals have been nonetheless within the early days of their collective trauma when speak pivoted to the rhetoric of conflict. Analogies have been made to shared cultural or nationwide tales from the previous: The terrorists have been “evil-doers,” President George W. Bush mentioned quickly after the assaults, and preventing them was “a brand new campaign.” September 11 was the “Pearl Harbor” that made it OK to invade Afghanistan.
By early 2002, Bush was telling the nation that Iran, Iraq and North Korea – the “axis of evil” – have been threats to america, though that they had not been implicated within the Sept. 11 assaults. His administration would quickly use its declare that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction as a “Gulf of Tonkin” second to justify the U.S. invasion of Iraq – a reference to the 1964 occasion that spurred larger American army involvement within the Vietnam Struggle.
As I listened to this kind of political rhetoric on the time, the language of Greek delusion and poetry helped me perceive how political speech capitalizes on reminiscence to create shared realities and justify use of violence. I spent that first 12 months of graduate college in New York Metropolis finding out the language and politics in Homer’s epic, the “Iliad.” The story’s “thousand ships” from totally different cities crusing east, with a bumbling idiot at their head, to punish the Trojans appeared an terrible lot just like the fractious “coalition of the keen” – Bush’s time period for the army alliance he assembled to invade and occupy Iraq.
[3 media outlets, 1 religion newsletter. Get stories from The Conversation, AP and RNS.]
Collective trauma and imperialism
Rome gives one other instance from historical historical past of the connection between collective trauma and justifications for imperial pursuits.
The town of Rome fought and gained its first conflict with the highly effective metropolis of Carthage – situated in what’s right now Tunisia – between 264-241 B.C., and its second between 218-201 B.C. Rome then imposed a hefty conflict indemnity on Carthage, which helped it purchase territories that laid the muse for a pan-Mediterranean empire.
These two victories ended any important risk that Carthage could have posed, however Roman tradition remained obsessive about conflict. In response to the army chief and creator Pliny the Elder, the statesman Cato the Elder used to shout “I believe Carthage should be destroyed” at each assembly of the Roman Senate. Rome went on to combat a 3rd conflict with Carthage, besieging and destroying town between 149-146 B.C.
I can’t consider this anecdote with out remembering how Bush agitated for invading Iraq over 10 years after his father’s invasion of the nation. Or that only a handful of years after Bush’s 2002 “axis of evil” speech, a presidential candidate sang “bomb bomb Iran” to the tune of a Seaside Boys pop hit.
These and different accounts from historical Greece and Rome recommend that over historical past, collective trauma has usually created a chance for leaders to make use of social reminiscence – a tradition’s shared tales – to create justifications for lashing out on the world, careless of any new harm it could trigger.
As people and nations, we don’t act due to what we endure, however usually due to the tales we inform about it.
Joel Christensen doesn’t work for, seek the advice of, personal shares in or obtain funding from any firm or group that will profit from this text, and has disclosed no related affiliations past their tutorial appointment.